Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
How We Tested These Subscription Boxes
We signed up for eight dog subscription boxes and received them over three consecutive months. Our panel of testers included a picky Shiba Inu, a power-chewing Pit Bull mix, a toy-obsessed Golden Retriever, and a senior Beagle with dietary restrictions. We evaluated each box on toy quality, treat quality, value (retail price of contents vs. subscription cost), customization options, and overall dog enthusiasm.
The 8 Best Dog Subscription Boxes
1. BarkBox (Best Overall)
Price: $35/month (less with longer plans)
BarkBox consistently delivered the most creative themed boxes with two toys, two treat bags, and one chew per month. The February box had a "Bark-entine's Day" theme complete with a plush heart toy and salmon jerky treats.
Best for: Dogs who enjoy plush toys and a variety of treats.
What we liked:
- Creative monthly themes
- Generous portion sizes on treats
- Easy to customize for allergies or toy preferences
- Responsive customer service (they replaced a toy our dog destroyed in 10 minutes)
What could be better:
- Toys are not built for aggressive chewers
- Treats tend to be grain-inclusive
2. Super Chewer by BarkBox (Best for Power Chewers)
Price: $45/month (less with longer plans)
If your dog destroys plush toys in seconds, Super Chewer is the answer. Every toy is made from tough rubber or nylon, and they are backed by BarkBox's "Scout's Honor" guarantee -- if your dog destroys it, they send a replacement.
Best for: Pit Bulls, Labs, and any determined chewer.
What we liked:
- Toys actually lasted with our Pit Bull tester
- Two tough chews included each month
- Same fun themes as regular BarkBox
- Destruction guarantee
What could be better:
- Higher price point
- Some rubber toys had a strong smell initially
3. PupBox (Best for Puppies)
Price: $39/month
PupBox tailors each box to your puppy's exact age, which means the toys, treats, and training guides evolve as your dog grows. Each box includes a training guide card that covers age-appropriate skills.
Best for: New puppy owners who want training guidance alongside toys and treats.
What we liked:
- Age-specific content is genuinely helpful
- Training guides are clear and practical
- Treats are appropriately sized for puppies
- Good variety of chew textures
What could be better:
- Less useful once your dog reaches adulthood
- Slightly less exciting packaging than BarkBox
4. Bullymake (Best Durability)
Price: $39/month
Bullymake focuses exclusively on tough dogs. Every toy is made in the USA from nylon, rubber, or ballistic material. They also offer a toys-only option if your dog has dietary restrictions.
Best for: Dogs who destroy everything and owners who are tired of replacing toys weekly.
What we liked:
- Toughest toys of any box we tested
- Made in the USA
- Flexible subscription (toys only, treats only, or both)
- Toys are designed for interactive play, not just chewing
What could be better:
- Toy designs are less creative than BarkBox
- Treat selection is smaller
5. Kong Box (Best for Mental Stimulation)
Price: $39.95/month
Every Kong Box includes a classic Kong toy or Kong-branded enrichment product alongside treats and a behavioral tip card. The focus is on mental stimulation and problem-solving.
Best for: Dogs who need mental enrichment and owners who love the Kong brand.
What we liked:
- Every box includes a Kong product
- Behavioral tips are written by certified trainers
- High-quality treats
- Good for dogs prone to boredom
What could be better:
- Less variety since everything is Kong-branded
- Price is higher relative to what you receive
6. Pet Treater (Best Budget Option)
Price: $25/month
Pet Treater delivers solid value at the lowest price on this list. Each box includes three to four items: a mix of toys, treats, and accessories like bandanas or waste bag holders. The quality is not premium, but the price-to-content ratio is strong.
Best for: Budget-conscious owners who still want a monthly surprise for their dog.
What we liked:
- Best value on this list
- Includes accessories other boxes skip
- Good treat variety
- Fun bandanas and seasonal items
What could be better:
- Toy quality is noticeably lower
- Less customization available
- Packaging is basic
7. The Dapper Dog Box (Best Presentation)
Price: $35/month
The Dapper Dog Box focuses on aesthetics. Each box is beautifully packaged with a themed bandana, two toys, and two or three treat bags. The bandana quality is genuinely impressive -- thick fabric with clean stitching.
Best for: Dog owners who love Instagram-worthy unboxings and stylish accessories.
What we liked:
- Beautiful presentation
- High-quality bandanas
- All treats are USA-made
- Eco-friendly packaging
What could be better:
- Toys are not built for tough chewers
- Smaller overall quantity of items
8. RescueBox (Best for Giving Back)
Price: $29.95/month
Every RescueBox purchase funds meals, toys, and supplies for shelter dogs. The box itself contains three to four items including treats, toys, and chews. The quality is mid-range, but the charitable component adds genuine value.
Best for: Dog owners who want their subscription to support shelter animals.
What we liked:
- Every box supports animal rescue organizations
- Treats are high-quality and sourced responsibly
- Good variety of items
- Feel-good factor is real
What could be better:
- Toy quality is inconsistent month to month
- Fewer items than some competitors
Quick Comparison Table
| Box | Price/Month | Best For | Toy Durability | |-----|------------|----------|----------------| | BarkBox | $35 | Overall value | Moderate | | Super Chewer | $45 | Power chewers | High | | PupBox | $39 | Puppies | Moderate | | Bullymake | $39 | Destruction-proof toys | Very High | | Kong Box | $39.95 | Mental stimulation | High | | Pet Treater | $25 | Budget-friendly | Low-Moderate | | Dapper Dog | $35 | Style and presentation | Low-Moderate | | RescueBox | $29.95 | Charitable giving | Moderate |
Our Recommendation
For most dog owners, BarkBox offers the best combination of quality, variety, and value. If your dog is a power chewer, skip straight to Super Chewer or Bullymake -- you will save money in the long run compared to buying toys your dog destroys in a day. And if you have a new puppy, PupBox is worth every penny for the age-specific training guidance alone.